Page 1 of 1

Top or Bottom

Posted: 21 Mar 2021, 22:33
by rod
♠ J9854
A5
K106
♣ J74

♠ 1062
KQJ82
872
♣ 82
♠ A3
96
J543
♣ K10953

♠ KQ7
10743
AQ9
♣ AQ6


Bidding proceeds:

South
1NT
2♠
3NT
West
Pass
Pass
Pass
North
2
2NT
Pass
East
Pass
Pass
Pass


Opening lead: K

Do you agree with the 3NT call, and does the scoring method matter for that?

As South would you win the first trick? I did. In that case 3NT can be beaten if East plays the 9 at trick one... otherwise the suit blocks when East later gets in with a spade trick and South ducks the 9. Would an expert East get this right even with standard signaling?

Discuss.

Re: Top or Bottom

Posted: 22 Mar 2021, 09:25
by rod
Seems to me East should get this right. He/she can count points and realize partner has no entry outside of hearts, and can visualise a layout such as the one at the table. There is little danger here in a misleading signal.

Maintaining this level of awareness is hard work. That's why defending well is difficult, at least for me!